This page is reserved for commentary on timely topics—including religion, politics and societal trends— with special emphasis on Essential Value and Individual Freedom.  Respond to: hampday1@verizon.net.

President Trump announced on Wednesday that America formally recognizes Jerusalem as Israel's capital city, and that the United States embassy in Israel would be moved there from Tel Aviv.  His proclamation was a bid to preserve, not derail, aspirations for regional peace, yet it was greeted by demonstrations in the Middle East and a threat from Hamas that he had 'opened the gates of hell'.  Palestinian secular and Islamist factions called a general strike on Thursday after tens of thousands took to the streets on Wednesday night.  World leaders—including the Pope—spoke out against the measure, claiming that it jeopardized the peace process.

Why all the fuss over a brief speech by a new American president intended to foster reconciliation between two opposing cultures? Every president since Bill Clinton has exercised a waiver in the Jerusalem Embassy Act, effectively kicking the can down the road. Trump said this has brought the world 'no closer to a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians.'  The major theme in Trump's unprecedented statement was that it shouldn't interfere with longer-term peace negotiations between Israeli and Palestinian leaders.  The issue he raises is a Tale of Two Cities.

King David conquered Jerusalem in 1000 B.C., built its first Holy Temple, and made it the capital of the Jewish kingdom.  Over the centuries Jerusalem was conquered and ruled by the Babylonians, Romans, Persians, Arabs, Fatimids, Seljuk Turks, Crusaders, Egyptians, Mamelukes and Islamists. Although Jerusalem isn't even mentioned in the Koran, and Mohammed never visited the city, Arabs claim it as the Islamic city of Al-Quds.  The coastal city of Tel Aviv, founded in 1910 by David ben Gurion, is currently governed by the Tel Aviv-Yafo Municipality and is home to many foreign embassies as well as a world financial center.

Israel is the only country where the U.S. has an embassy in a city that is not named as its capital.  Since the Palestinians do not recognize Israel as a sovereign nation, having to negotiate with Jews in their historic city of Jerusalem is an insult.  Benjamin Netanyahu praised Trump's decision, saying that "Jerusalem has been the capital of the Jewish people for 3,000 years."  Yet he never made it official.  Could the reason be political correctness?    

This week a trio of AP journalists reports on the merits and pitfalls of this record-setting proclamation.  Was it a political blunder, or will it help forge a peace agreement between Israel and Palestine?  Let us have your thoughts, at hampday1@verizon.net.

  

--HP  

         THE MARCH WILL CONTINUE UNTIL THE PALESTINIAN FLAG FLIES IN JERUSALEM  -Y. Arafat                  

                

 

 

 

 

 Trump declares Jerusalem Israeli capital, smashing US policy

by  Josef Federman, Karin Laub, Josh Lederman*  [Filed 12/06/17]

 

President Donald Trump shattered decades of unwavering U.S. neutrality on Jerusalem Wednesday, declaring the sorely divided holy city as Israel's capital and sparking frustrated Palestinians to cry out that he had destroyed already-fragile Mideast hopes for peace.

Defying dire, worldwide warnings, Trump insisted that after repeated peace failures it was past time for a new approach, starting with what he said was his decision merely based on reality to recognize Jerusalem as the seat of Israel's government.  He also said the United States would move its embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, though he set no timetable.

"We cannot solve our problems by making the same failed assumptions and repeating the same failed strategies of the past," Trump said, brushing aside the appeals for caution from around the world.

Harsh objections came from a wide array of presidents and prime ministers.  From the Middle East to Europe and beyond, leaders cautioned Trump that any sudden change on an issue as sensitive as Jerusalem not only risks blowing up the new Arab-Israeli peace initiative led by Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner, but could lead to new violence in the region.

No government beyond Israel spoke up in praise of Trump or suggested it would follow his lead.

Israelis and Palestinians reacted in starkly different terms.  Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hailed Trump's announcement as an "important step toward peace," and Israeli opposition leaders echoed his praise.  But Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said Trump's shift serves extremist groups that want religious war and signals U.S. withdrawal from being a peace mediator.  Protesters in Gaza burned American and Israeli flags.

Trump's declaration of Jerusalem as Israel's capital is a powerfully symbolic statement about a city that houses many of the world's holiest sites.  Trump cited several: the Western Wall that surrounded the Jews' ancient Temple, the Stations of the Cross that depict Jesus along his crucifixion path, the al-Asqa Mosque where Muslims say their Prophet Muhammad ascended to heaven.

And there are major ramifications over who should control the territory.  The United States has never endorsed the Jewish state's claim of sovereignty over any part of Jerusalem and has seen the city's future as indelibly linked to the "deal of the century" between Israel and the Palestinians that Trump believes he can reach. Beyond Kushner, Trump has dispatched other top emissaries to the region in recent months in hopes of advancing new negotiations.

Trump said he wasn't delivering any verdict about where an Israeli-Palestinian border should lie.  Instead, he described his Jerusalem declaration as recognizing the reality that most of Israel's government already operates from the city, and he suggested the U.S. ally should be rewarded for creating a successful democracy where "people of all faiths are free to live and worship."

"Today we finally acknowledge the obvious," he said, emphasizing that he wouldn't follow past presidents who tiptoed around Jerusalem out of diplomatic caution.

U.S. embassies and consulates around the world were put on high alert.  Across the Middle East and Europe, they issued warnings to Americans to watch out for violent protests.  In Jordan, home to a large Palestinian population, the U.S. said it would close its embassy to the public Thursday and urged children of diplomats there to stay home from school.

Later Wednesday, the State Department issued an updated "Worldwide Caution" to U.S. citizens abroad, advising travelers to "be alert to the possibility of political unrest, violence, demonstrations, and criminal activities."

There was little in Trump's statement to encourage the Palestinians.  Although he recited the longstanding U.S. position that Jerusalem's borders must still be worked out through negotiation, he made no recognition of the Palestinian claims to east Jerusalem.

For the first time, Trump did appear to endorse the concept of an independent Palestine existing alongside Israel.  Yet even that idea appeared conditional, as he said he'd promote the "two-state solution" if both sides agreed.  Netanyahu's government is dominated by hardliners who oppose Palestinian independence.

Trump made no reference to signing a waiver that officially delays any move of the U.S. Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, but the White House confirmed he signed the waiver Wednesday.  It means there will be no embassy move for at least another six months.  Establishing a Jerusalem embassy was a major campaign promise of Trump's and one that officials said he focused on in discussions with top advisers in recent weeks.

On Wednesday he focused on his directive to the State Department to begin a process of moving the embassy as required by U.S. law, however many years that might take.  After his speech, he signed a proclamation to that effect.

In Germany, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said work will begin immediately to identify a site.

A non-governmental expert on the Middle East who consults regularly with the White House said the Trump administration had opted against an earlier plan of converting the existing U.S. Consulate in Jerusalem to an embassy.  Instead, it's looking to construct an entirely new facility, said the individual, who wasn't authorized to disclose private conversations with U.S. officials and requested anonymity.

In making his decision, Trump overruled more cautious counsel from Tillerson and Defense Secretary James Mattis, who voiced concern about endangering U.S. diplomats and troops in Muslim countries, according to officials briefed on internal administration deliberations.  Those officials were not authorized to publicly discuss the matter and spoke on condition of anonymity.

"There will of course be disagreement and dissent regarding this announcementbut we are confident that ultimately, as we work through these disagreements, we will arrive at a place of greater understanding and cooperation," Trump said.  He said he intends "to do everything in my power to help forge" a peace agreement.

In making his decision, Trump overruled more cautious counsel from Tillerson and Defense Secretary James Mattis, who voiced concern about endangering U.S. diplomats and troops in Muslim countries, according to officials briefed on internal administration deliberations.  Those officials were not authorized to publicly discuss the matter and spoke on condition of anonymity.

"There will of course be disagreement and dissent regarding this announcement, but we are confident that ultimately, as we work through these disagreements, we will arrive at a place of greater understanding and cooperation," Trump said.  He said he intends "to do everything in my power to help forge" a peace agreement.



*Josef Federman in Jerusalem; Karin Laub in Amman, Jordan, and Josh Lederman in Brussels are Associated Press writers.  This report was filed Wednesday, December 6, 2017 ©The Associated Press.

 

Did  you  miss  these  recent  EV   articles?   Read  or  print  them  now . . .

  Acknowledging a Universe by Design

Trying to Quantify Reality

 The Essence of Our Reality

  Confessions of a Moral Relativist

  Deciphering the Master Plan

  The Welfare State vs. Values and the Mind

  Do Americans Still Value Freedom?

  Vive la Différence!

  Empires Also Die

  Individualism in Philosophy

  The Stupidity of Attacking ID

  The Great Utopia

  Is 'Discrimination' a Bad Word?

  The Failure of Socialism

  Is there Life after Death?

  The Moral Basis of Capitalism

  Your Self as a Value Detector

  On Becoming Aware

  Pondering Pure Nothingness

  Crime and Punishment

  The Curse of Misplaced Altruism

  The Axiology of Essential Value

  Religion Invalidates Freedom

  Value is the Essence of Life

  A Critical Look at the Koran

  What Islam Needs Now

  The Free Will Defense

  Consciousness and Reality 

  From Nothingness to Value Realized

  Values Affirm what Essence Negates

  Get  SEIZING THE ESSENCE   HERE  NOW !  

Amazon e-Books: Seizing The Essence